Can you use the VAT margin scheme on your Whatnot sales?
Yes, if three conditions line up on the same item. HMRC puts it plainly on its VAT margin schemes guidance: you can choose to use a margin scheme, item by item, and you do not register for it separately. So the useful question works at item level: does this particular card qualify?
The three conditions: VAT-registered dealer, second-hand goods, bought without VAT
First, you must be VAT-registered and selling as a business. A private collector clearing a binder does not charge VAT at all, so the margin scheme simply has nothing to do. If you are unsure which side of that line you stand on, start with the guide on whether you are a hobby seller or a business on Whatnot.
Second, the goods must be second-hand goods, works of art, antiques or collectors' items. HMRC's definition of second-hand goods is broad: tangible movable property that is suitable for further use as it is or after repair.
Third, the item must have been bought without VAT being charged to you. That condition decides most Whatnot cases.
Who you can buy from
The eligible sources are:
- private individuals (a collection bought on Facebook Marketplace, a lot from a car boot sale, a jacket from a charity shop, a single from a seller on eBay or Vinted UK);
- businesses that are not VAT-registered and therefore charged you no VAT;
- other dealers who sold to you under a margin scheme themselves, such as a card shop issuing a margin scheme invoice.
Exclusions: items you were charged VAT on, your own imports, precious metals
Three families stay outside. The first is any item you were charged VAT on, and gov.uk is explicit about it. Then come goods you imported yourself, apart from works of art, antiques and collectors' items (VATMARG07000). Last, precious metals and investment gold follow their own rules.
The "private seller" who isn't
A seller who looks like a private individual can be a VAT-registered trader. If an eBay or Vinted UK seller lists dozens of identical sealed boxes, ask for their status and keep the listing and the messages alongside the payment trail. Your stock book entry is only as good as the evidence behind it, and HMRC can refuse the margin scheme where you cannot show the item reached you without VAT.
Flat Rate Scheme users: you can't run both
This is the friction point most small resellers discover too late. VAT Notice 733 (section 6.4) states that a Flat Rate Scheme user cannot use a margin scheme at the same time. Precisely, the choice is made once, for the whole business.
If you are on the Flat Rate Scheme and buy most of your stock from the public, run the numbers before your next VAT period. A flat percentage applied to gross turnover can cost far more than one-sixth of a thin margin on second-hand stock. Leaving the Flat Rate Scheme is a decision for the whole business, so model a full quarter before you switch.
How to calculate margin scheme VAT: the formula and a worked card example
The margin is the selling price minus the purchase price. The VAT due is one-sixth of that margin, because the margin is treated as VAT-inclusive at the standard rate of 20%. For the rest of the UK regime (reduced rates, zero-rating, returns), see the full guide to VAT in the United Kingdom.
Take a Charizard bought from a collector for £40 and sold on a live show for £100:
| Step | Margin scheme | Full price (standard rating) |
|---|---|---|
| Selling price | £100 | £100 |
| Purchase price | £40 | not deducted |
| Taxable amount | £60 margin | £100 |
| VAT due | £10 (£60 × 1/6) | £16.67 (£100 × 1/6) |
| VAT saved | £6.67 |
Across a year of singles bought from the public, that gap often separates a profitable stream from a break-even one.
Item by item: a negative margin is simply lost
Under the standard method, each item has its own margin. If you paid £80 for a card and sold it for £60, the VAT due on that sale is £0. The £20 loss does not reduce the VAT on your other sales. There is no carry-forward and no netting across items.
Global Accounting: one margin per VAT period, for items bought for £500 or less
The Global Accounting Scheme lets you work out one margin for the whole VAT period instead of one per item. You total the purchase prices of eligible goods bought in the period, total the selling prices of eligible goods sold, and apply the one-sixth fraction to the difference.
A month of Pokémon singles: £2,400 of sales, £1,500 of purchases, a global margin of £900, so £150 of VAT. If purchases exceed sales in a period, the negative margin is carried forward to the next one.
The scheme has a cap: each item must have cost £500 or less. Vehicles, motorcycles, boats and outboard engines, aircraft, caravans, horses and ponies are excluded whatever the price. When you stop using Global Accounting, you add the purchase price of your closing stock to your sales, unless the VAT due on it would be under £1,000.
An item that cost you more than £500 does not lose the margin scheme. It only leaves Global Accounting and is accounted for item by item. Many summaries say "over £500 means standard rate": wrong, the £500 caps the global method, not the margin scheme itself (gov.uk guidance on Global Accounting, VATMARG03200). A £1,200 graded card bought from a collector still goes under the margin scheme, on its own line in the stock book.
Bulk collections bought for one price: apportion, or go global
Buying a binder of 300 cards for one price is common. Item by item, you must split that price fairly, with a method you can explain (market values on the purchase date work well). Under Global Accounting, a bulk lot can go in even if it cost more than £500, provided no single item in it, taken alone, is worth more than £500 (VATMARG03200). In practice, pull out the high-value hits, record them individually, and put the rest into the global pot.
Whatnot fees, postage and grading: what counts in the margin
Here the two meanings of "margin" part ways. Your commercial margin is what is left after costs; your VAT margin is selling price minus purchase price, nothing else. Whatnot fees, postage and grading are not deducted from the VAT margin. HMRC is clear that you use the total price paid for the item and must not add any other costs, including repairs, parts and overheads.
The VAT on those overheads is another matter: Whatnot's commission and payment fees follow its current fee schedule, and they are business costs. As a VAT-registered seller, any VAT on them, invoiced or self-accounted under the reverse charge, goes through your normal return.
Graded cards, sealed product, opened boosters: what goes under the margin scheme
The decision turns on one question: were you charged VAT when you bought it? The table sorts the situations Whatnot resellers actually meet.
| Situation | Margin scheme? | VAT base | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Single bought from a private collector | Yes | Margin | Bought without VAT |
| Graded card bought from a private individual | Yes | Margin | Grading fee stays outside the purchase price |
| Card bought from a shop selling under the margin scheme | Yes | Margin | Supplier's invoice shows no VAT |
| Sealed box bought from a private collector | Not settled | Have your case validated | No HMRC ruling on sealed product |
| Sealed box bought from a distributor | No | Full price | You were charged VAT |
| Cards pulled from a distributor box | No | Full price | Same VAT-charged purchase |
| Cards imported yourself from Japan or the US | No | Full price | Own imports excluded |
| Vintage clothing bought at a charity shop or car boot sale | Yes | Margin | Second-hand, bought without VAT |
A trading card is second-hand goods, not a collectors' item, for UK VAT
Collectors' items have a legal meaning in VATA 1994, section 21(5): stamps, coins, and pieces of historical, archaeological or scientific interest, among others. HMRC's definition of collectors' items does not cover trading cards, and no HMRC publication names Pokémon cards. So cards fall under the general heading of second-hand goods. The practical consequence: no reduced 5% import rate for cards, and no margin scheme on cards you import yourself.
Sealed product bought from a private collector: the grey area
Whether sealed product bought from a private collector can go under the margin scheme is a particular case HMRC has not settled: have your situation validated before relying on one reading. In the meantime, document every purchase.
Cards pulled from a distributor box: standard-rated (the break trap)
A break seller buys a sealed display from a distributor and is charged VAT. On stream, the box gets ripped and the hits go up for sale. Every one of those cards is standard-rated, singly or in lots, because the goods came from a VAT-charged purchase. Opening the box does not turn the contents into second-hand goods. The upside: you recover the input VAT on the display.
Give every item a stock number the day you buy it, and add a source code: P for private seller, M for margin scheme dealer, D for distributor. When a collection card and an identical pulled card share a drawer, that code alone tells you which VAT treatment applies.
Vintage and second-hand fashion
Vintage denim bought from private sellers fits the scheme, and so do trainers or designer pieces sourced the same way. One nuance: children's clothing is zero-rated in the UK, so there is no VAT to save on it and the margin scheme brings nothing.
Mixed parcel: two schemes in one Whatnot order
A buyer can win a margin scheme single and a standard-rated pulled card in the same show. Issue separate lines, the margin scheme one with no VAT shown, and never let a single VAT figure cover both.
Invoicing under the margin scheme on Whatnot
A margin scheme invoice follows its own rules, on top of the general invoicing rules in Great Britain. The central one: no VAT is shown, anywhere.
The wording HMRC expects, word for word
Each sales invoice must carry the date, your name, address and VAT number, and the buyer's name and address. Add the item's stock book number, the invoice number, a description and the total price, with no separate VAT. It must also state the scheme used: "Margin scheme - second-hand goods", or the variants for works of art, collectors' items and antiques. Under Global Accounting, the invoice says "global accounting invoice" in addition.
No VAT on the invoice: what to check before you send it
If VAT appears on a margin scheme invoice, the sale is outside the scheme and VAT is due on the full price. HMRC's guidance also says you cannot go back and apply a margin scheme later to a sale you invoiced with VAT.
Invoicing tools on selling platforms are usually set up for standard-rated sales. Before you rely on any invoice generated for your Whatnot orders, open one, check that no VAT line appears for margin scheme items and that the scheme wording is there. If the tool cannot do it, issue your own margin scheme invoices from your accounting software.
Stock book and purchase records: what HMRC requires
In the UK, records are a legal condition of the scheme: without them, VAT is due on the full selling price (VATMARG10000).
Three documents carry the weight:
- A purchase invoice for every item bought from a private individual, which you write yourself. It shows the seller's name and address, your name, address and VAT number, an invoice number, the date, the stock number, a description and the total price paid.
- A stock book with, for each item, the stock number, purchase and sale dates, invoice numbers, purchase and selling prices, seller and buyer details, description, margin and VAT due.
- The supplier's margin scheme invoice when you buy from another dealer.
Keep everything for 6 years. The real risk in a check is losing the margin: VAT recalculated on the full price, plus inaccuracy penalties of up to 30% of the extra tax for carelessness.
Selling to EU and Northern Ireland buyers from GB: export rules
A card sent from Great Britain to a buyer in Germany or Italy is an export. It is zero-rated if you hold proof that the goods left the UK, as VAT Notice 703 sets out on gov.uk. OSS has nothing to do with it: that is an EU system. For consignments of €150 or less, the EU import VAT is usually handled through the platform under IOSS. Above that, the buyer pays EU import VAT and any duty on delivery.
Northern Ireland follows EU rules for goods under the Windsor Framework. Second-hand goods bought in Great Britain and resold to a Northern Ireland buyer generally cannot go under the margin scheme. Works of art, antiques and collectors' items are the exception.
The VAT registration threshold is counted on your full sales
The most expensive misunderstanding comes last. The £90,000 VAT registration threshold applies to your taxable turnover over the last 12 months, rolling. That turnover counts the full selling price of your goods (VATREG02400). Margin scheme sales count in full. You must also register if you expect to exceed £90,000 in the next 30 days alone. Deregistration is possible below £88,000.
A reseller who sells £95,000 of cards in a year for a £20,000 margin must register, even though the margin looks small. The margin scheme only kicks in after registration, which is why it matters to get a UK VAT number at the right moment, before HMRC writes to you.
Need help with your Whatnot VAT?
The margin scheme cuts the VAT on every eligible sale, as long as the paperwork holds up item by item. Eurofiscalis maps where your stock comes from and helps you choose between item-by-item and Global Accounting. We can also take your UK VAT returns off your hands.
Book a call with a specialist →
Reviewed by Jimmy Sagnier, VAT Specialist at Eurofiscalis.
FAQ
How do I report margin scheme sales on my VAT return?
Box 1 takes the VAT due on your margins. The full selling price of margin scheme sales, minus that VAT, goes in Box 6, and the purchase price of eligible goods bought goes in Box 7. Boxes 8 and 9 stay empty. Returns go through Making Tax Digital software; see the UK VAT return deadlines and MTD for timing.
Do I need to register for the margin scheme?
No. The margin scheme is optional and has no registration of its own. You simply apply it to eligible items, keep the stock book and invoices it requires, and report the figures on your normal VAT return. You can also choose to standard-rate an eligible sale if that suits the buyer.
Hobby seller or trader: when does the margin scheme matter?
Only once you are trading and VAT-registered. A hobby seller clearing a personal collection charges no VAT and needs no scheme. A reseller buying to resell is trading, and once turnover passes £90,000 the margin scheme becomes the tool that keeps VAT on second-hand stock at a sensible level.
I'm not VAT-registered: does the margin scheme apply to me?
No. Without a VAT registration you charge no VAT, so there is no margin to tax. Any VAT included in the platform's fees then becomes a cost you cannot recover. Your one obligation is to watch your turnover against the £90,000 threshold, and remember that it counts full selling prices, every card included.
Can I reclaim VAT on Whatnot fees, grading or postage?
Yes, if you are VAT-registered. Those are overheads, and their input VAT goes through your return like any business cost. What you cannot do is add them to the purchase price of the item: the VAT margin stays selling price minus purchase price, with no costs added.
Can a business buyer reclaim VAT on a card sold under the margin scheme?
No. A margin scheme invoice shows no VAT, so the buyer has nothing to reclaim. If a VAT-registered shop buys from you and wants to recover VAT, you can standard-rate that sale instead, show the VAT, and give up the margin treatment on that item.
Can cards imported from Japan or the US go under the margin scheme?
No. Goods you import yourself are excluded, and trading cards are not collectors' items. You pay import VAT, which postponed import VAT accounting lets you handle on your return, and the resale is standard-rated. Overseas sellers should also read about selling on Whatnot without a UK establishment.
Does Whatnot collect VAT for me?
Mostly no. Whatnot acts as deemed reseller on imported consignments of £135 or less, where the margin scheme plays no part. On your margin scheme sales, calculation and reporting stay with you. The detail is in the guide answering does Whatnot collect VAT.
Does Whatnot report my sales to HMRC?
Yes, above the reporting limits. The UK Reporting Rules for Digital Platforms (SI 2023/817) apply since 1 January 2024. Whatnot reports sellers who make 30 sales or more in a year, or receive more than about €2,000. The guide on does Whatnot report to HMRC covers it.
Countries concerned